This is the order of the next round of testimonies. Also listed is race, reliability of testimony, and biased for or against Katie Cleage. After these will come a wrap-up and decision regarding Katie’s pension. (I figured out how to make a table and that made transcribing the table so much easier!)
Pages
Names of Witnesses
Exhibits
Depositions
Reputation
1
2
Notice to Claimant
A
3-4
Summary
5-7
Claimant’s statement
B.
Good
8-9
John H. Cleage (white)
C.
Good – Biased against
10
Mrs. T. A. Cleage, Sr (white)
D.
Good – Biased against
11-12
David Bridges (colored)
E.
Good – Unbiased
13-14
Millie Valentine (colored)
F.
Good – Unbiased
15-16
Edmonia Charlton (colored)
G.
Good – Unbiased
17-18
Isaac Charlton (colored)
H.
Good – Unbiased
19-20
Minerva Allen (colored)
I.
Good – Unbiased
21-23
Lucy McCaurey (colored)
K.
Good – Unbiased
24-25
Charles A. Cleage (colored)
L.
Good – Biased against
26-27
Thomas Bradford (colored)
M.
Good – Biased against
28-30
Sallie Clegg Marsh (colored)
N.
Good – Biased against
31
James F. Bradford (white)
O.
Good – Unbiased
32-33
Patsey Clegg (colored)
P.
Doubtful – Biased against
34-35
Adeline Sherman (colored)
R.
Doubtful – Biased against
36-37
Katie Clegg (claimant)
S.
Good – Unbiased
38-41
Jemima Cleage (white)
T.
Good – Unbiased
42-43
Lucy McMaurey (colored)
U.
Good – Unbiased
44-45
John L. Atlee, M.C. (white)
V.
Good – Unbiased
46
Copy of record from
W.
I found the information for this post in Katie Cleage’s Civil War Pension.
Case of Katie Cleage No. 288,39128 March 1890 at Chattanooga, Hamilton, Tennessee
Jemima Cleage That she is 77 year of age and that her post office address is No. 114 Sycamore St. Chattanooga, Tenn
Jemima Hurst Cleage, age 52
Katie Cleage was my
slave from the time she was about 13 years old until she gained her freedom.
She had two children while she was my slave, but I know of no marriage by her
to any one. Philip Cleage was one of our servants, but I know of no marriage
between these two parties. I know of no cohabitation between these parties. We
owned a hundred slaves at that time, and I know but very little of any of them.
Katie was employed as a seamstress by us, and Philip was our coachman. Philip
enlisted in the army and came to Chattanooga, and Katie came here also. I do
not know who came first. Philip came back to see us after he had enlisted, but
Katie had left in the meantime. I know nothing of either of them after that
time. I know of no marriage or cohabitation between them after they left our
house at Athens. I have seen Katie occasionally since the war. I know of no
children Katie has had since the war. It is since the soldier Philip died of
smallpox during the war, I guess it was.
I
have understood the questions asked me, and the answers to them have been
correctly recorded in this deposition.
Jemima Cleage
***************
Jemima Hurst married Alexander Cleage in 1832. She brought with her four enslaved people. Their names were Anny, Judi (my 2X great grandmother), Jane and Matilda.
In his Will written in 1833, Jemima’s father, Elijah Hurst, left her those four women “… I will and bequeath to my daughter Jemima Cleage and her heirs forever the four negroes (sic) she has had possession of Big Anny, Judi, Jane, and Matilda together with all the other property I have given her.”
Jemima’s husband, Alexander, wrote in his Will “I give and devise to my beloved wife Jemima Cleage for and during her natural life the following described negro (sic) slaves – to wit: … Juda and her five children to wit: Charles, Angelen, Lewis, Laura and Frank… I also give and bequeath to her for her natural life a negro (sic) man called Frank the husband of Juda…” 30th day of May 1860 Alexander Cleage
Juda and Frank were my 2 X great grandparents. Lewis was my great grandfather. It gives me some comfort to know that they had been free for almost ten years by the time Alexander Cleage died in 1875.
Case of Katie Cleage 22 March 1890 Chattanooga, Tennessee Woodson Weaver
That he is 45 years of age: that he is a Hackman by occupation and that his post office address is No. 305 Spring St. Chattanooga, Tenn.
I was first duty
sergeant of Co. “G” First USCH Artillery. I knew Philip Cleage only in the
army. I do not know what became of him. I do not know whether he is living or
dead.
Katie Cleage was Philip’s wife. They “went” as man and wife in the army. If she hadn’t been his wife they would not let her stay there. They went together, had a tent in camp and passed as man and wife. I often seen them in the tent together and she used come and stay there for three and four days at a time and no woman unless she was married to a soldier was allowed to remain there. Everyone in camp knew they were man and wife, and considered them as such. I know nothing about their marriage. I only know of them cohabiting together as man and wife in the army.
I
have known Katie ever since the war. She has not married since Philip died. I
do not know whether she has had any children or not since the war as I never
visit her house. I only know her in passing and re-passing on the street.
I
am in no way related to the claimant and have no interest in her claim.
I
have understood the questions asked me, and the answers to them have been
correctly recorded in this deposition
Woodson Weaver (His mark)
************
There was no new information in Woodson Weaver’s short testimony so I decided to look at his life and write something about him. At first I was confused at finding a Woodson Weaver in Knoxville, and then in Chattanooga and then in Cincinnati, Ohio. I wondered if I had the same man. I decided that the man in Knoxville was the same man in Chattanooga because once he moved, no Woodson Weaver was found in the records in Knoxville. I was not sure about the Woodson Weaver I found in Chattagnooga until I found his find-a-grave record which showed that he had served in Company G, 1st US Colored Heavy Artillery, which I knew he had.
It was at that point that I decided to search for Woodson Weaver in newspapers and found a disturbing and widely covered event involving his family.
Woodrow Weaver was born into slavery in Wagner, Kentucky about 1845. He was brought to Tennessee at some point and in 1864 he enrolled in Co. G of the USC Heavy Artillary in Knoxville, TN. He was mustered out in March 1866 in Knox County. In December of the same year he married Nancy Rice. Before he was married, his son John Weaver was born, mother not known.
Woodrow and Nancy stayed in Knoxville where he worked as a railroad laborer. By 1880 they had relocated to Chattanooga. In 1884 he began receiving a pension for disability. He had a hearing loss. Nancy returned to Knoxville and died there in 1887. Woodrow worked as a drayman and a laborer. In 1888 his son James Washington/Weaver was born to Rachel Washington. They did not stay together. In 1896 and 1897 we find Woodrow Weaver in Cincinnati, Ohio working as a peddler. His son John shared the house at 1123 Lincoln Avenue and worked as a laborer.
In September of the following year, 1898, the two story frame house burned to the ground. The family lived on the first floor and the Maceo Club, a black political club, had the rooms upstairs. The club was named for the black Cuban Revolutionary, Antonio Maceo. The newspapers of the day were full of stories about the Cuban fight to free themselves from the Spanish. The fire started in the club rooms.
In early 1899, Woodson Weaver re-married. His wife died mysteriously soon after the marriage.
In mid May, disaster struck the family. The father Woodson and the son John were both struck down by poison. “Rough on Rats” had been added to their morning coffee. John Weaver died later that day at City Hospital. Sixty year old Woodson Weaver was seriously ill for months. He finally recovered, but never fully regained his health.
Papers all over the country carried sensational stories about the murder. James served a little over a year before he was pardoned and sent home to his mother where he died of consumption
Click to enlarge
In the 1900 census, several months before Jimmie died of consumption. He is listed in his mother Rachel’s household, along with an older sister, Katie 19 and a younger brother, Clarence 8. Katie Washington died in 1903 of consumption. She was 22. Rachel died in 1910 at age 55 of Bronchitis. I lost track of Clarence after the 1920 census in Chicago, Illinois.
Woodson Weaver died at the age of 67 in 1907. He never recovered his strength after the poisoning.
********
Resources I used for this post include: Katie Cleage’s Pension file, Ancestry.com (censuses, city directories, death records); Newspapers.com.; FamilySearch.org, marriage records and GenealogyBank
Second statement from James Royal in which we learn Katie was in camp with Philip five months before he died.
Deposition E
James Royal
22 March 1890
That he is 46 years of age; that he is a laborer by occupation; and that his post office address is No. 301 Harrison Avenue, Chattanooga, Tennessee.
I
was a private in Co. “A,” first U.S.C. Heavy Artillery. I enlisted when the
regiment was organized and served until March 31, 1866.
I
knew Philip Cleage in my company. I stood on guard with him enough to know him.
There in Chattanooga, Philip was taken to the smallpox hospital, and died
there, so it was said. I saw them when he was put in the ambulance, and never
seen him after that.
Katie,
the “widow,” was introduced to me by Cleage as his wife. I heard Cleage speak
of his wife before I saw her. The first time I saw her was in Camps here in
Chattanooga, some five months before he was taken sick. They lived and
cohabited together in camps as man and wife. I know this because I saw them
occupying the same tent and same bunk together, and the officer of the regiment
recognized Katie as Philips’ wife. No unmarried “children” or women were
allowed in camps. Everyone knew Katie and Philip as man and wife.
I
have not seen Katie and have known nothing of her since they took Philip from
the camp.
Katie
was present when they took Philip to the hospital, and she cried and wanted to
go with him to wait upon him, but they wouldn’t allow her to do that.
I
am not related to the applicant, and have no interest in her claim.
I
have understood the questions asked me, and the answers to them have been
correctly rendered in this deposition.
James (his mark X) Royal
***********
I found the information for this post in Katie Cleage’s Civil War Pension file.
That
he is 49 years of age; that he is a painter by occupation and that his post
office address is Chattanooga, Tenn. (corner of Hurricane Avenue and Line Streets.)
Philip
Cleage served in the same camp with me: Co. “A” First U.S.C.H. Artillery. I
knew Cleage for three or four years before the war. He was the slave of Alex Cleage,
of Athens, Tenn., and I used to live up there. Cleage was a hale and hearty man
up to the time he was taken sick with smallpox here in Chattanooga. This was a
short time before the regiment was mustered out. He was taken to the hospital
here, and then died of smallpox. I was doing camp guard duty and passed him out
to the hospital. He was taken away in an ambulance and in a few days I heard of
his death. It was said he had black
smallpox.
In
6 or 8 months after we were mustered in at Knoxville, the whole company was claiming
for a furlough. Capt. Elliott wanted to know who were married and who single,
as he wanted to grant the married men a furlough. Cleage and I got a furlough,
as we were both married men. I didn’t know who his wife was at that time. I
first knew of his marriage to Katie, the applicant, here in Chattanooga, when
she came to the camp in the spring of 1865.
I
was first duty sergeant of the company, and had orders to keep all women out of
camp, except married women. Katie came there and was admitted as Philips wife.
They lived and cohabited together in camp as man and wife. Two women and two
men occupied the same cabin and Philip and Katie were two of them. I didn’t
know the other couple. They lived together as man and wife until Philip was
carried away to the hospital. Philip stated to me time and time again, that he
had been married to Katie and that she was his lawful wife. I haven’t a bit of
doubt that Philip and Katie were lawfully married under the slave customs,
though I was not a witness to the marriage ceremony. The officers all recognized them as man and
wife and no question was raised as to their presence in camp.
I
have seen Katie nearly all the time since the war and know that she has not
remarried – at least I have no knowledge of the fact if she had been. She has
two illegitimate children since the war.
I remember Cleage got a furlough for the purpose, as he said, of going to see and get his wife. I don’t think he brought her back. This was while we were at Knoxville, not Chattanooga. This was when we had been in the service 7 or 8 months it is a mistake in my affidavit where it says Cleage got a furlough at Chattanooga, in 1865. But after they came together in Chattanooga, they lived together as man and wife and he introduced Katie as his lawful wife.
I
am in no way related to the claimant and have no interest in her claim.
I
have understood the questions asked me, and the answers to them have been
correctly recorded in this deposition.
Isaac Charlton
****************
Hamilton County Courthouse. Isaac Charlton worked here as janitor for several years. In 1910 it was struck by lightening and burned down.
Isaac Charlton was born into slavery in North Carolina about 1840. He was in the USC Heavy Artillary troop with Philip Cleage. After mustering out, Isaac and his wife Mahala remained in Chattanooga. According to the 1870 census, Mahala could not read or write while Isaac was literate.
Isaac Charlton signed his name on his deposition instead of marking it with an “X”.
Mahala died soon after 1870. Issac married Edmonia Scruggs. They had one daughter, Josephine who was born in 1873. Edmonia was literate and Josephine attended school through the 5th grade. Over the years Isaac worked as a janitor in the courthouse, a porter at a store, a painter and a laborer.
In 1879 Isaac applied for and received his invalid pension for Civil War service. He died when he was 51 and is buried in the National Cemetery in Chattanooga. Because I do not have his pension file, I do not know what exciting information may be there.
Isaac’s wife Edmonia filed for her widow’s pension the month after Isaac’s death. She moved to Knoxville and worked as a cook. She died there of pneumonia on April 6, 1906. She was 58 years old. Edmonia is buried in the Daughters of Zion Cemetery in Knoxville.
Josephine spend some time in Alabama, where she married and gave birth to a daughter. She eventually returned to Knoxville and died there in 1955 at 82 years of age.
********
Resources I used for this post include: Katie Cleage’s Pension file, Ancestry.com, Hamilton County Tennessee Geneology Society, google search.
This is the house that Alexander Cleage purchased in 1860, about the time he bought Katie. The columns were not added until 1930, so they were not there during the life times of the people in this pension file. The porch where he married Katie and Philip was probably around back or on the side, but I could not see it on google maps. “In 1860 Alexander Cleage, another prominent settler, acquired the farm and house for $20,150 ($609,921.08 in today’s money.) The Civil War practically bankrupted Cleage and the property was sold after his death in behalf of his creditors.” You can read details about this house in the application for designation as an historical site.
Deposition “C”
Case of Katie Cleage March 1, 1890 Chattanooga, Hamilton, Tennessee.
Before me, R. C. Getchell, a special examiner of the Pension Office, personally appeared Katie Cleage, who being by me first duly sworn to answer truly all interrogatories propounded to …
That she is 41 years of age; that her post office address is No. 519 Cedar St., Chattanooga, Tenn.
********
I am the widow of Philip
Cleage, the soldier. I just know Philip was a soldier and belonged to the first
U.S. H Artillery. I don’t know what company he belonged to.
I was married to Philip Cleage before the war – I was about 16 years old when we got married. We were married at Athens, Tenn., and my old master, Alex. Cleage, married us. My master told me that I must marry one of the home boys, and so I married Philip. We were married at our master’s house, right in the porch. My master read a passage from the Bible and then told us we were man and wife. There was no one present at the marriage, except us two and the old master. I disremember whether the war was going on or not at the time we were married. It was long before Sherman’s men came along. I was 13 years old when my master bought me, and I guess it was about three years after that when we got married. I lived with Philip before we got married, and that’s why we came to get married. Cleage found out that I had been living with Philip and then he made us marry. I had just one child before we married and this child was born dead. I had another child in the next year after our marriage and this one lived but one day. Philip was living at the time this second child died. This was all the children I ever had by Philip. I have had two children since my husband, both of them are now living. These children are both illegitimate, as I have never married since Philip died.
I married Philip before he was mustered in the army. We had been married a good while before he enlisted. We lived and cohabited together as man and wife from the time of our marriage until he enlisted. We lived with Mr. Cleage all the time and we were both his slaves. Mr. Cleage is dead, but his wife is still living.Philip had right good health from the time of our marriage to his enlistment. He went into the army and died a soldier. He died in hospital, of smallpox. I didn’t know where the hospital was located. I was with Philip when he first come out with small pox. I was in camps with him when he broke out with smallpox. It was here in Chattanooga at his camps. I sewed in the regiment, and went to him and slept with him every night from the time the regiment came to Chattanooga until he broke out with smallpox. He was taken sick, and Dr. Wright, the surgeon of the regiment, said he had smallpox. I seen him all broken out with smallpox. After I gave him his tea, he broke out with smallpox, and was then sent to the hospital and I never saw him live any more. They sent me word that he was dead shortly after he was taken to the hospital. I wanted to go to the hospital with Philip; but the doctor said I mustn’t as I would die too if I went. He had the black small pox, so it was said. I had the (looks like: varalid) just after Philip died. I was vaccinated long before I married Philip.
(Question: were people being vaccinated for small pox on plantations in the 1800s?)
Can you make out the highlighted word?? varolid? Answer (variolid) and more information in the comments section.
The children I have had since my husband died are both living. One of them will be seven the first of next June, and the other five on the first of next April. I have had sexual intercourse with but one man since my husband died, and he is the father of these two children. This man is a married man. He is a colored man, and has a wife living. He was not married at the birth of the first child. I had no intercourse with this man after the birth of the second child. I had the man arrested and tried to get him to support the children and every once in awhile he would bring me some money. This man’s name is John Washington and he lives here in Chattanooga. No, I was never married to Washington. I had him arrested for bastardy. I never lived with him at all. I cohabited with him just long enough to have these two children. They put him in jail when they arrested him; and I didn’t know what they did with him. I swear positively that the only man I ever married was Philip Cleage. I have never got any bounty or back pay, but have made application for both.
I was working here in Chattanooga when my husband’s regiment came here. My husband heard of my being here, came and got me and took me into camps, and I went and stayed with him every night until he was taken down sick. No objection whatever was made to my going into camp and living with my husband. I “served out” every day, but did all his washing.
I was a seamstress at my master’s house, but I slept with Philip every night. They gave us a room in which to sleep. Philip was employed on the farm and I in the house.
In camp, my brother and his wife and Philip and I staid together in one tent, occupying two bunks. My brother, Abe Cleage, went to Texas years ago, and I don’t know where he is now. The last I heard of his wife, she was in Rome, GA. I haven’t heard from her for a good many years. John Rowland and Ike Chilton know that we lived and cohabited together here as man and wife. I have lived here since the war. Everybody knows I haven’t remarried.
I was engaged to be married to Washington, but the marriage was broken off. This was why I had two illegitimate children by him. Both children were born before he married another woman.
I have understood the questions asked me, and the answers to them have been exactly recorded in this deposition.
Tomas Giffe Katie Cleage X (her mark) N.C. Gelchell
*************
You can read some of Katie’s brother Abe’s story here Abraham and Amanda Cleage I have learned much more about them since receiving their pension files and I will be writing about them in the future.
I found the information for this post in Katie Cleage’s Civil War Pension file, on ancestry.com and familysearch.org.
When I first induced Capt. Thomas Giffe to take charge of my claims it had remained dormant for nearly five years and I had well nigh despaired the case, but, now I have good hopes of succeeding, and I thank Mr. Giffe for it. He is the only person who I gave any authority to, that I have any recollections of.
I
cannot read or write and I do not know nor recollect what has been written in
my name heretofore. I have all confidence in Mr. Giffe. I desire that he be
recognized as my atty. In fact, I found that it was impossible for me to get
anything done correctly without employing any atty. here who could do my
writing for me. I am willing to pay Chas and Has B King for anything they may
have done for me, but I cannot consent to give them the credit of working up
this case, after 5 years delay. I have paid them as follows – 1st
$2, 2nd $1.50 in stamps and 3rd $1.00 making $4.50
altogether.
Katie Cleage (X her mark)
**********
An interesting and informative article about Civil War Pensions that explains who was eligible, how much they received and how these both changed as time passed. Civil War Pensions.
“The Civil War pension system was color blind in that there was nothing in the application process that required applicants to be white. But recent scholarly works have made it clear that the process itself was far from color blind. Because African American soldiers were both less likely initially to be assigned to combat roles, and then less likely to be hospitalized (early disability applications required documentation from hospitals) if injured, they could not produce the documentation required by the application process. And they were less likely than their white counterparts to have the money necessary to complete the process. Ultimately the fate of black veterans’ applications was decided by white bureaucrats who found it easy to turn them down without fear of retribution. An interesting side note is that the Grand Army of the Republic actively campaigned for their black brethren to be granted pensions just as white veterans were.”
It was also often more difficult for formerly enslaved widows to prove they had been married because of the lack of documentation for “slave marriages”.
*************
Thomas Giffe, Atty Click to go to original photograph site
Thomas Giffe, Katie Cleage’s lawyer, was born in Ireland and came to the United States as a young man. He enlisted in the 74th Regiment, Ohio Infantry and was later appointed Captain of Company H, U.S. Colored Troops 16th Infantry Regiment. USCT regiments were led by white officers. After the war Giffe and his family lived in Chattanooga where he was a contractor, a businessman, an attorney and an active member of the Grand Army of the Republic (G.A.R.)
I found the information used in this post on ancestry.com, Katie Cleage’s Pension file, Chattanooga Newspapers, Newpapers.com . The photograph is from the website of The Tennessee Library (Knoxville)
Claim of Katie Cleage, Widow of Sgt. Philip Cleage deceased late of Co. “A” 1st regiment U.S.C.H.A.
Personally
came before me Isaac Carleton, aged 49 years a citizen of the town of
Chattanooga, County of Hamilton, State of Tennessee
I was a sergeant in the same company and regiment. With Philip Cleage. I knew him before he enlisted, and we were sworn in the same day. I did not know his wife at that time but he claimed to be a married man and in 1865 after our Regiment came to Chattanooga he obtained a furlough to go see his wife and when he returned he brought Katie with him and introduced her as his wife and they cohabited together until he took the small pox and was sent to the pest camp and even then she followed him to wait upon him but they refused to admit her. He died and she has not remarried and still mourns him as her deceased husband to this day. Sgt. Cleage died about one or two months before the Regiment was mustered out.
I further declare that
I have no interest in said case and am not concerned in its prosecution.
Isaac Carleton
********
I found the information for this post in Katie Cleage’s Civil War Pension file.
Chattanooga. View from Lookout Mountain. February 1864. Photographer George N. Banard
General Affidavit
State of Tennessee County of Hamilton 4 Dec 1889
I, James Royal aged 46 years a citizen of the town of Cohutta in county of Whitfield state of Georgia. I, James Royal, was a private soldier in Company “A” 1st Regiment U.S.C. Heavy Artillery and first met the claimant Katie in Chattanooga when Sgt. Philip Cleage brought her into the camp of the same regiment and he introduced her to me as his wife. At all events, they lived and cohabited together in camp where no woman was allowed to remain unless she had a husband to protect her and when the ambulance came to move him to the smallpox camp, she insisted on going along to wait on him and nurse him, but I stood aloof and they took him away and the next thing I heard that he had died and I never saw her since.
My present P.O. address is Sherman Heights – Hamilton Co. Tenn. My home is Cohutta GA. I further declare that I have no interest in said case and am not concerned in its prosecution.
James Royal X his mark
Click image to enlarge ************
I found the information for this post in Katie Cleage’s Civil War Pension file and on ancestry.com.
Affidavit of Mrs. Jemima Cleage: The former owner of both Philip and Katie when slaves
11
Dec. 1889
Jemima Hurst age 52
I am the widow of Alexander Cleage deceased, late of Athens, McMinn County, Tennessee. I recognize the applicant, Katie, as one of our former slaves. My husband purchased her when quite a child, 13 years old, from my brother Russell Hurst – we then resided on a farm about 3 miles from Athens and my brother’s farm was about 6 miles distant.
All the ceremony at that time necessary for slaves to marry was the consent of the owners. I think it was in December 1862, Katie was delivered of a stillborn child. And again in December 1863 of another stillborn child. And I was present at the birth of both children.
In December 1863 Philip left us, all the slaves having been liberated by proclamation of the President, and I heard that he had joined the army. Katie remained with us some 8 months after Philip left us and then she went off.
I
further state they both were very young and had not been previously married and
I have never heard that she remarried. She was always a good clean girl and I
kept her in the house to sew. I know
what I here state from personal recollection. I have not seen her for a long
time.
And
I further declare that I have no interest in said case and am not concerned in
its prosecution.
Jemima Cleage
***********
I found the information for this post in Katie Cleage’s Civil War Pension file.
